Crystalbrook Albion and The Old Clare offer two well-defined starting points for a Sydney boutique stay. Albion has 35 rooms and a rooftop garden in Surry Hills. The Old Clare occupies two heritage-listed buildings in Chippendale and lists a rooftop pool and bar. [S3][S4]
Consider Albion for its small scale and shared garden; consider The Old Clare if its heritage setting and listed facilities suit your plans. These are feature-based judgments, not claims from personal stays. The shortlist is deliberately limited to two verified properties.
At a glance
Compare the stays
On a small screen, scroll across the comparison.
| Hotel | Neighborhood | Character and shared spaces | Important room / facility check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crystalbrook Albion[S1][S3] | Surry Hills | 35 rooms; rooftop garden; Honour Bar | Baths are listed in selected rooms. The garden is not a verified swimming facility. |
| The Old Clare Hotel[S4][S5] | Chippendale | Two heritage-listed buildings; rooftop pool and bar | Layouts vary. Pool hours, access conditions and any fees require confirmation for your dates. |
Consider for a small hotel with a shared garden
Crystalbrook Albion
21 Little Albion Street, Surry Hills, NSW 2010, Australia
Albion's address is 21 Little Albion Street in Surry Hills, Sydney. Use that property-specific address when planning arrival, rather than an address for another hotel in the Crystalbrook collection. [S2]
The hotel combines heritage details with contemporary furnishings and individually designed rooms. Its facilities list includes 35 guest rooms, 24-hour hosts, an Honour Bar and a rooftop garden. [S1][S3]
The practical appeal is a small-scale hotel with somewhere to spend time outside the room. Do not turn the rooftop garden into a pool expectation. Bathtubs are listed only for selected rooms, so a particular bathroom setup needs to be matched to your booking. [S3]
Choose the room for its actual features, not a photograph from another category. Check bath availability if it matters; the hotel also describes itself as cash-free.
Consider for heritage buildings and a rooftop pool setting
The Old Clare Hotel
1 Kensington Street, Chippendale, Sydney, Australia
The Old Clare's current official site uses Ode Hotels branding and places the hotel at 1 Kensington Street, Chippendale. The property spans two heritage-listed buildings; its facilities include a rooftop pool and bar, restaurant, gym and 24-hour reception. [S4]
Room layout deserves attention here. The Chippendale Loft, for example, has a lounge on the lower level and a sleeping and bathing area upstairs. That specific arrangement can matter if you want separate living space, or if changing levels would be inconvenient. [S5]
That is one category, not a description of the whole hotel. Compare the category you will actually book, and request a suitable layout directly if step-free access is essential.
The hotel lists a rooftop pool, but this comparison does not establish its current hours, heating, eligibility or charges. Ask for those details rather than assuming year-round swimming.
Choose the feature you will actually use
If you want a modest room count and a shared outdoor garden, start your enquiries with Albion. If you want the combination of heritage buildings and a listed pool/bar, start with The Old Clare and confirm the pool's rules. Neither is automatically the better hotel for every trip.
Then compare the addresses against your own plans. Surry Hills and Chippendale are different bases; avoid deciding from the word “Sydney” alone. This guide has not timed journeys or inspected neighborhood noise, so it does not promise a particular commute or a quiet room.
What to check on the booking screen
Compare the same dates, occupancy and cancellation terms. A large photograph may show a suite or a different category from the lowest displayed rate.
- Match the room name, bed setup and maximum occupancy to your party.
- Confirm any feature you care about: a bath, separate lounge, accessible bathroom or step-free route.
- Check whether breakfast or other inclusions belong to the selected rate, rather than the hotel generally.
- Ask about the operating hours and access conditions of the shared facility you plan to use.
- Review the full total, payment method and cancellation terms before paying.
What “boutique” means in this comparison
The selection is based on identifiable character, accommodation and shared spaces. It is not a star classification, a promise of independent ownership or an exhaustive ranking of Sydney hotels.
We have not assigned review scores, tested service or sleep quality, or verified live prices. An amenity on an official website supports its inclusion in the description, but it does not establish availability for a particular stay. Check the dated sources below and confirm the details that determine your choice.
Check the details
Sources & verification
Hotel policies can change. These are the pages used for this comparison; a checked date is not a promise of availability.
- S1Crystalbrook Albion: hotel overview
Current hotel identity, Surry Hills location and individual room design. Checked 11 November 2026.
- S2Crystalbrook Albion: contact and address
The hotel's own address: 21 Little Albion Street, Surry Hills NSW 2010. Checked 11 November 2026.
- S3Crystalbrook Albion: facilities
35 rooms, host service, rooftop garden, Honour Bar, selected-room bathtubs and cash-free operation. Checked 18 November 2026.
- S4The Old Clare Hotel: current official overview
Current branding, Chippendale address, two heritage-listed buildings and listed hotel facilities. Checked 18 November 2026.
- S5The Old Clare Hotel: Chippendale Loft
This room category has two levels: a lower lounge and upper sleeping/bathing area. Not a description of every room. Checked 11 November 2026.